Best 22 of the combined 3 Flags ? | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Best 22 of the combined 3 Flags ?

Interesting exercise. Do you pick the players who played the best in the grand finals or those who contributed most to the dynasty?

I'll go for what I think would make the best team, with weighting to GF performances. And it's 23 a side now, so that's how many I'm picking. (I notice Mr B had 23 in his best 22 also.)

B: Grimes Rance Astbury
HB: Vlastuin Broad Houli
C: Pickett Martin Caddy
HF: Lambert Edwards Bolton
F: Rioli Lynch Riewoldt
R: Nankervis Cotchin Prestia
I: Short Graham Castagna Grigg Balta
E: Baker McIntosh Butler Ellis

Tough to leave out Baker. It was down to him or Balta and I felt Balta's move into the ruck just before half time of the 2020 grand final was more impactful than anything Bakes did in a grand final. Balta also gives me cover in every area and position.

I know Grigg was only a oncer and with Balta in I don't need him to play second ruck, but like Rance his leadership and smarts helped establish the dynasty. I want hard runners on the bench, and he was also a legit stoppage mid. Bakes, for all I love him, is a small flanker at the level, and I have Lambert, Bolton, Rioli, Houli and Short already.


You need to rewatch the 2020 grand final. Bolton was in the best handful on the ground.
Grimes.....Rancey......Broad
Flossy.......Astbury.....Baker
Rioli..........GOAT.........Pickett
Shedda.....Lynch........Bolton
Caddy.......JR8.............Townsend

Nank....Chimp....Meatball

Balta....Houli....Lambert....Castagna
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Vlastuin Rance Grimes
Broad Astbury Houli
KMac Lambert Grigg
Nank Cotchin Prestia
Bolton Lynch Rioli
Edwards Jack Dusty

Graham Short Pickett Baker

God damn that's a good side.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Vlastuin Rance Grimes
Broad Astbury Houli
KMac Lambert Pickett
Cotchin Martin Prestia
Bolton Lynch Rioli
Edwards Jack Caddy

Graham Short Grigg Soldo

God damn that's a good side.

Running with the ruckmen (Soldo and Grigg) starting on the bench????

Cotchin is good but 1st ruck???
 
I know Towner is a favourite of all of us but to me there is no way he makes that team. His was a legendary cameo, one that will be spoken about by Tiger supporters for a long time. The spot where he buried a Crouch is a shrine on the MCG.

In terms of contribution over that time Caddy, Pickett, Graham, Castagna, Baker, Grigg and Ellis would all get picked before him in my team
 
  • Like
  • Angry
  • Dislike
Reactions: 6 users
I know Towner is a favourite of all of us but to me there is no way he makes that team. His was a legendary cameo, one that will be spoken about by Tiger supporters for a long time. The spot where he buried a Crouch is a shrine on the MCG.

In terms of contribution over that time Caddy, Pickett, Graham, Castagna, Baker, Grigg and Ellis would all get picked before him in my team
He should be captain
 
  • Haha
  • Love
Reactions: 3 users
I know Towner is a favourite of all of us but to me there is no way he makes that team. His was a legendary cameo, one that will be spoken about by Tiger supporters for a long time. The spot where he buried a Crouch is a shrine on the MCG.

In terms of contribution over that time Caddy, Pickett, Graham, Castagna, Baker, Grigg and Ellis would all get picked before him in my team
I haven't named a "best 22 of the combined 3 flags" because I wouldn't wont to leave anyone out.

Deep into the 2nd quarter and 8 points down when Towner laid that bone cruncher, and then kicked a goal a few minutes later.
How could I leave Towner out of a best 22, he turned the 2017 GF around for us with that tackle, and laid another ripper of a tackle in the middle of the ground a bit later too.
Towner showed his teammates what winning takes, he inspired them to win the game.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 1 users
I'd go with all the players in the 2017 team.

They were the epitome of a team, and delivered the most unexpected flag against, IMO, the best opponent out of the three flags.

I'd back that team against any team. The obvious inclusion would be Lynch, and then possibly a second ruckman (with all due respect to Grigga).

But even still, that 2017 combination just found a way, and as Wayne Carey said at the time, "Their gameplan just stands up in finals footy.


So 2017 for me no changes.
Kinda forgotten how good the Crows were in 2017. Slaughtered sides home and away. Piled on big scores. Our GF performance was incredibly mature and disciplined.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I haven't named a "best 22 of the combined 3 flags" because I wouldn't wont to leave anyone out.

Deep into the 2nd quarter and 8 points down when Towner laid that bone cruncher, and then kicked a goal a few minutes later.
How could I leave Towner out of a best 22, he turned the 2017 GF around for us with that tackle, and laid another ripper of a tackle in the middle of the ground a bit later too.
Towner showed his teammates what winning takes, he inspired them to win the game.
He was great for a period of 7-8 weeks and on that day but I reckon there is a bit of mayo on your take. There were lots of heroes that day, he was just one of them.
 
He was great for a period of 7-8 weeks and on that day but I reckon there is a bit of mayo on your take. There were lots of heroes that day, he was just one of them.
Yes there were a lot of heroes "that day", but we eight points down deep into the 2nd quarter and only just going until Towner loosened Crouch's fillings with that tackle, he then kicked the next goal. Towner inspired his teammates and we we went into half time leading by 9 points. We smashed them in the 2nd half.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 1 users
Yes there were a lot of heroes "that day", but we eight points down deep into the 2nd quarter and only just going until Towner loosened Crouch's fillings with that tackle, he then kicked the next goal. Towner inspired his teammates and we we went into half time leading by 9 points. We smashed them in the 2nd half.
We had turned the game by then. Jack had kicked a goal and the game was starting to be played on our terms. We had lifted and our pressure was well up, Towner’s tackle was in that period.
Don’t get me wrong I loved the role he played that day and in the finals but the game had started to turn already, it didn’t happen because of the tackle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
We had turned the game by then. Jack had kicked a goal and the game was starting to be played on our terms. We had lifted and our pressure was well up, Towner’s tackle was in that period.
Don’t get me wrong I loved the role he played that day and in the finals but the game had started to turn already, it didn’t happen because of the tackle.
Agree to disagree.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Putting my internet dad hat on, Jayden Short is a walk up start in any grand final combined side.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Kinda forgotten how good the Crows were in 2017. Slaughtered sides home and away. Piled on big scores. Our GF performance was incredibly mature and disciplined.
Some blokes played great games but whet unheralded.

Broad carved up Tom Lynch in the 2017 GF who was their key forward conduit target from defence to attack, all season and Towner and Caddy kept the Crows key backs from getting to Jack.

Broad also did some work on Toby Greene the week prior in the Prelim in 17.
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: 1 user
Jacob T and caddy are first picked and the rest are just along for the ride

you know it's true

Happy New Year PRE
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 1 user
Agree to disagree.
that tackle by Towner was the turning point of the game

before that the game was in the balance...........then BANG !!!! ............a crow player is sitting in the third row

and that when the tiger machine got going
 
  • Love
Reactions: 1 users