Have been reading everything here since the announcement but didn't want to join the commentary.
But this probably best sums up my take on things.
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Alex Rance
- Thread starter Tigers of Old
- Start date
Have been reading everything here since the announcement but didn't want to join the commentary.
But this probably best sums up my take on things.
Soldo in particular looked to be getting better at positioning himself in the holes late in the season. Real old school ruckman style. Benny would have been proud. Funny how our shape has almost come full circle. A traditional marking tall monstering the forward line and rucks who can tap and defend. While other clubs will be (are) trying to mimick our 2017-2019 style we continue to evolve. Loved Jack's comment - goosebumps as others have said. I believe we'll miss Tross most when the opposition have a big marking forward also.
Yep, it is taking a while as you would expect, but Soldo is learning to read the game a whole lot better. He can be very useful down back and occasionally forward. Add in a tall back, maybe Balta though not convinced he is suited (CCJ maybe, ruck and defence?) but I do think we need a defender around 195cm (6'5") or taller for the tall forwards.
DS
I hate the word when it comes to footy. It'll be used to beat us over the head if we fall short of winning the flag. I'm disowning it totally.
In other words, the biggest football-related concern for 2020 is...
“What if they rip on us for not being a dynasty?”
The club has sure come a long way!
My bulldog supporting brother in law , always says , he shouldve been father son for the dogs, his dad Murray didnt quite play enough games........I didnt know any better ,
Just read page 1 and an article there says his dad played 40 for the dogs and 57 for the eagles , pretty funny really, nowhere near father son material for the dogs
Just read page 1 and an article there says his dad played 40 for the dogs and 57 for the eagles , pretty funny really, nowhere near father son material for the dogs
It's just an arrogant wank word. Dominance is dominance. Premierships are premierships.
Yeah, just reckon we need one more tall back with Rance going, he was around 195 too wasn't he?
DS
Close. 194. Grimes is listed as 193 I think, and Broad is 192. I agree that another big guy would be useful. I hope Balta can be developed into the role.
I don't think either the club or Balta himself knows his best position yet. Hopefully we will find out in 2020
Yeah I would back Bolter to replace Rance as he appears to have that free spirit which Rance displayed from day one. Bolter very green at the moment but give him a permanent role down back he will mature quite quickly.
The thing that Rance had early that Balta doesn't have is an innate ability to read the play and intercept
He’s not Rance (no one is or will be) but Pretty sure I can recall a couple of super intercepts in Adelaide leaving his man and streaming up the middle of the ground to set up or kick goals.
Although having a high level defensive instinct is invaluable, do you all recall the Benny Hill-esque theatrics in our back 50 when we had Rance learning defence with Luke McGuane?
Those times prove that you can LEARN how to defend.
Rance turned into the AFL's best defender in around 3 years of perseverance under the guidance of an experienced defensive coach.
We still have Leppa in our coaching team and I am confident that one of our talls such as Balta can step up if required.
Rance had the tools to succeed, I believe Balta especially, has them too.
Those times prove that you can LEARN how to defend.
Rance turned into the AFL's best defender in around 3 years of perseverance under the guidance of an experienced defensive coach.
We still have Leppa in our coaching team and I am confident that one of our talls such as Balta can step up if required.
Rance had the tools to succeed, I believe Balta especially, has them too.
Last edited:
One thing Balta would have that Alex didn’t early days was a settled, tight, experienced defensive unit that know their job and do it better than any other in the comp.
