2005 Player of the year | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2005 Player of the year

Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3. Tuck
2. Simmonds
1. Brown

Unlucky, Richo, Gaspar, Cogs
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3. Graham (shut down the potentially most dangerous player out there)
2. Tuck (Took on the best midfield and beat them)
1. Cogs (as above)

I'd give TW votes if I could! What a transformation!
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3. Tuck
2. Coughlan
1. Gaspar
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3. Brown
2. Tuck
1. Simmo

To all Hawthorn supporters - HA HA - we've got Tucky and Terry Wallace.
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

This is the hardest decision I have had to make all weekend. (And I just finished watching the game. Thankfully CMT wasn't here)

3. TUCK (how could he not get a game last year)
2. Cogs (Poise Under pressure was sensational)
1. Newman (sensatinal skills) ToO you owe me

This was one of the best efforts I have seen in a while. Meyer is going to be a superstar and will pass all expectation in my book. Poise under pressure in the guts was sensational tonight. This kid has it all. To who ever said Lids had a shocker on Tiger Talk. Dont come here. His pass to brown in the 3rd quarter under pressure was exquisite. Hyde No ill effects.....Thought the young guys were sensational tonight. May not have been match winners, but Myer won me tonight.....he has it all.......just needs to fill out a bit, but proved that build is not the be all. maybe those who wanted him back at coburg 2 weeks ago need to have a rethink.

*smile* is quicker than I thought. Still room for Jacko...drop tivers he cost us about 3 goals...I have not mentioned him before, but his kicking was at U13 level tonight
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3 votes--Tuck..In and under and great skill.
2 votes--Kellaway...Raw courage and knows no fear.
1 vote--Johnson...great captains game.

With apologies to Browny and Graham...Can't fit everyone in.
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3 - Tuck

2 - Gaspar

1 - Simmonds

Great effort by the whole team
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

Harry said:
3. Tuck
2. Coughlan
1. Gaspar

What Harry said! Brown did what he had to do - eventually, Graham did what he was asked to do - no more, Kellaway was brave - what he has to do, but apologies to Richo!
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3 - Tuck - Pure awesome display over 4 Qtrs.
2 - Graham - Ran himself to the ground & shut down the Brown monster
1 - Cogs - Mr Consistent

I think a few teams might notice us coming.
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3 - TUCK- gonna win the brownlow this year!!
2- Richo - gotta love seeing him take a mark on the last line of defense
1- Gas - HE's BACK

^^^^^TUCK 4 BROWNLOW^^^^^
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3. tuck
2. gaspar
1. knobel (i reckon he was wonderful, but no one else has mentioned him)

i also thought that kellaway, richo, simmonds, cogs, pettifer, johhno were very good, as were graham and lids)
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3. TUCK (probably the only decent thing spud did)
2. COUGHLAN (I love his footy)
1. BROWN (champion)
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 9 v Brisbane

3. Tuck
2. Cogs
1. Johnson