2005 Player of the year | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2005 Player of the year

Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

krakouer Magic!! said:
3 votes - Browny
2 Votes - Cogs
1 Votes - Richo                   

And worst on ground for this game and worst in the team so far would be Trent Knoble WORST PICK UP EVER.


Did you watch the game, Krakouer?
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

3-Brown
2-Richo
1-Cogs

krakouer Magic!! said:
And worst on ground for this game and worst in the team so far would be Trent Knoble WORST PICK UP EVER.

LOL-Good One! You obviously didn't see the game. That was the best game I have EVER seen TK play.
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

Return of Cynicism said:
Yes mate for player of Trent Knoble's standards i suppose you could say he played a good game but than rate him against other number 1 ruckman from the other teams in the league and his endeavour on the ball and also on the man being his large statue is highly abysmal.

Calm down buddy, I don't think any of us expected Scott Wynd when TK was drafted. Most of the people on PRE (including me) felt that Knobel was servicable against Freo.
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

That winning feeling...Luv' it!!
3. Brownie
2.Son of Bull
1.Simmo
                 Bring on the Saints... :thumbsup :tigerhead.. Go Tiges
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

Return of Cynicism said:
Yes mate for player of Trent Knoble's standards i suppose you could say he played a good game but than rate him against other number 1 ruckman from the other teams in the league and his endeavour on the ball and also on the man being his large statue is highly abysmal.

Without Trent there would have to be Ben Marsh for Terry to use his triangle.

3. Brown: Any player who gathers 38 possesions in a game of footy deserves 3 votes
2. Richo: Any player who kicks 4 goals in a quarter also probably deserves 3 votes unfortunately there are rules
1. Hyde: Dont wanna put any pressure on the kid, but I believe the pressure he puts on the opposition around the midfield and his hard work at stoppages is the main reason for Brown and Richo starting the season so well. Hopefully it will also be the reason for Browny winning the Brownlow and Richo winning the Coleman. Oh, and of course Richmond winning the premiership. As I said no pressure!!! ;) ;) ;)

One week at a time thank you boys.
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

3- Brown
2- Richo
1- Hyde

I hope it's not (but fear it might be) back to reality against our bogey-side this week. Just keep the % above 100 fellas!

RL37
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

3- Coughlan
2- Brown
1- Hall

Tough round for votes. Too many vying for them, not the 2004 not enough worthy of them. :)

Hope we have the same problem next week. :bash :angel: :bash
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

Watching the replay again thought that Newman and Bowden were very unlucky not to get any or more votes.
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

Harry said:
Watching the replay again thought that Newman and Bowden were very unlucky not to get any or more votes.

Will be interesting to see the Club B&F at the end of the year if this keeps up.
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

3. Brown
2. Richo
1. Cogs

Dyer'ere said:
Tough round for votes. Too many vying for them, not the 2004 not enough worthy of them. :)

Hope we have the same problem next week. :bash :angel: :bash

Hear hear! :clap
 
Player of the year - Round 4 v St Kilda

Results from Round 4

Brown - 164
Richardson - 140
Coughlan - 82
Knobel - 9
Hall - 8
Hyde - 8
Gaspar - 4
Chaffey - 3
Kellaway - 3
Newman - 2
Simmonds - 1
Stafford - 1
Tivendale - 1

Progressive Total

Richardson - 481
Brown - 361
Hyde - 222
Gaspar - 138
Coughlan - 112
Newman - 111
Tuck - 98
Bowden - 44
Pettifer - 36
Johnson - 24
Hartigan - 12
Knobel - 9
Deledio - 8
Hall - 8
Campbell - 7
Kellaway - 6
Graham - 4
Chaffey - 3
Stafford - 2
Krakouer - 1
Simmond - 1
Tivendale - 1

Please remember 3-2-1 votes and nicknames I will understand.

Thanks.
 
Re: Player of the Year - Round 4 vs Fremantle

Tiggytam said:
VOTING IS NOW CLOSED FOR ROUND 4   :police:      ;D

DOh! I just finished watching the game!

Not that it will count, but anyway:

3 - Coughlan - Masterful job on Haselby
2 - Brown - Nearly every touch gold
1 - Richo - WHen he's firing we are always a chance

sp. mention Knobel - loved the 1%'s and he scored the first goal of the game - got us going.
 
Re: Player of the year-2005

I had Cogs 3 then I was wondering whether I could put a couple of backmen in, maybe Gas and AK, but didn't know if I could justify it ahead of Matty and Nathan. I think I took a bit long to ponder cos I forgot to put my votes in anyway.
 
Re: Player of the year - Round 4 v St Kilda

probably the 8th, 9th and 10th best on field after a plethora of sainters...

3 - Tuck
2 - Stafford
1 - Campbell
 
Re: Player of the year - Round 4 v St Kilda

useless.......

3. Hall
2. Gaspar
1. Jackson