Coaches votes- 2013

[Barnzy]

Really interesting that both coaches thought Gibbs third best on ground when the media generally had him as BOG.

I thought Cotchin was actually down on his normal output, although his defensive and ball winning efforts in the last were exceptional.

The Tuck, Jackon thing is interesting. One coach thought one was pivotal while the other thought they were not top 5.

Wonder who was who?

Agree.

Thought Gibbs outperformed Cotchin and he's a tad lucky to get the full 10. If Carlton won I'm guessing Gibbs gets 10.

 

[Brodders17]

Richmond vs St. Kilda
10 Riewoldt (Rich)
6 Conca (Rich)
4 McEvoy (St K)
4 Riewoldt (St K)
3 Cotchin (Rich)
2 Deledio (Rich)
1 Dal Santo (St K)

 

[Danog]

Richmond vs St. Kilda
10 Riewoldt (Rich)
6 Conca (Rich)
4 McEvoy (St K)
4 Riewoldt (St K)
3 Cotchin (Rich)
2 Deledio (Rich)
1 Dal Santo (St K)

I didn't notice *smile* Nil Santo at all.

 

[Smoking Aces]

I didn't notice *smile* Nil Santo at all.

Agree. I had Montagna well ahead of Dal Santo.

 

[taztiger4]

I didn't notice *smile* Nil Santo at all.

Or should that be Nil *smile* Santo !!

 

[Tigerfan]

I didn't notice *smile* Nil Santo at all.

I noticed Jacko had his lead and council registration papers

 

[year of the tiger]

Richmond vs St. Kilda
10 Riewoldt (Rich)
6 Conca (Rich)
4 McEvoy (St K)
4 Riewoldt (St K)
3 Cotchin (Rich)
2 Deledio (Rich)
1 Dal Santo (St K)

Hardwick Walters
Jack 5 Jack 5
Conca 4 McEvoy 4
Cotchin 3 Nick 3
Lids 2 Conca 2
Nick 1 Dal Santo 1

 

[French Tiger]

Hardwick Walters
Jack 5 Jack 5
Conca 4 McEvoy 4
Cotchin 3 Nick 3
Lids 2 Conca 2
Nick 1 Dal Santo 1

Got to love Watters, team loses & puts 3 out of 5 Saints in

 

[seven]

Hardwick Walters
Jack 5 Jack 5
Conca 4 McEvoy 4
Cotchin 3 Nick 3
Lids 2 Conca 2
Nick 1 Dal Santo 1

Walters has McEvoy over Nick & Conca?
He played well, but not that well. :

 

[Brodders17]

Got to love Watters, team loses & puts 3 out of 5 Saints in

Walters has McEvoy over Nick & Conca?
He played well, but not that well. :

i am assuming they are YOTT's guess on the votes, not the actual coaches votes. they votes could have fallen a few different ways.

 

[Tigerfan]

At least we know Hardwick and watters agreed on Jack and Conca even if Watters couldn't find the love to put Conca quite as high as Dimma.

 

[Brodders17]

At least we know Hardwick and watters agreed on Jack and Conca even if Watters couldn't find the love to put Conca quite as high as Dimma.

or both coaches gave Conca 3 votes.

 

[Dyer'ere]

or both coaches gave Conca 3 votes.

Ed Zachary. And greatly disagreed on McEvoy and N. Riewoldt.

A B
Jack 5 Jack 5
McEvoy 4 N. Riewoldt 4
Conca 3 Conca 3
Lids 2 Chimp 2
Chimp 1 Dal Santo 1

 

[year of the tiger]

i am assuming they are YOTT's guess on the votes, not the actual coaches votes. they votes could have fallen a few different ways.

yep correct - my assumptions only

 

[Brodders17]

Richmond vs Western Bulldogs
10 Martin (Rich)
8 Deledio (Rich)
6 Cotchin (Rich)
2 Grigg (Rich)
2 Houli (Rich)
1 Maric (Rich)
1 Riewoldt (Rich)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ttnews[tt_news]=1097&tx_ttnews[backPid]=9&cHash=66aa8233c4

 

[Tiger Rob]

By my reckoning Chimp would be on 5 Brownlow votes based on the coaches votes - a 3, a 1 and a 1. But the umpires love him, so could be as high as 10 Brownlow votes.

 

[mj72]

By my reckoning Chimp would be on 5 Brownlow votes based on the coaches votes - a 3, a 1 and a 1. But the umpires love him, so could be as high as 10 Brownlow votes.

As high as 10? I know the chimp is good but...

 

[zippadeee]

Richmond vs Western Bulldogs
10 Martin (Rich)
8 Deledio (Rich)
6 Cotchin (Rich)
2 Grigg (Rich)
2 Houli (Rich)
1 Maric (Rich)
1 Riewoldt (Rich)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ttnews[tt_news]=1097&tx_ttnews[backPid]=9&cHash=66aa8233c4

Morris unlucky.
Houli great stuff
& grigg too

 

[T-Shirt Tommy]

Morris unlucky.
Houli great stuff
& grigg too

 

[Dyer'ere]

Richmond vs Western Bulldogs
10 Martin (Rich)
8 Deledio (Rich)
6 Cotchin (Rich)
2 Grigg (Rich)
2 Houli (Rich)
1 Maric (Rich)
1 Riewoldt (Rich)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ttnews[tt_news]=1097&tx_ttnews[backPid]=9&cHash=66aa8233c4

A whole lot of concensus there from the coaches.