A discussion on the main board about how to assess draft picks got me thinking. What is a good draft pick? What is the best ever draft pick?
What do you think is the greatest draft pick ever? No rules, use your own criteria. Do the greatest ever, do a top 5, do whatever you want. It could be just the best player, eg Dusty, could be a star taken at a low pick, it could be Bakes etc etc. Would you dismiss a pick because it was just dumb luck? And elevate a pick because it was inspired?
Only rule is you have to explain your reasoning.
First thought was Nathan Fyfe, but I'll think on it.
What do you think is the greatest draft pick ever? No rules, use your own criteria. Do the greatest ever, do a top 5, do whatever you want. It could be just the best player, eg Dusty, could be a star taken at a low pick, it could be Bakes etc etc. Would you dismiss a pick because it was just dumb luck? And elevate a pick because it was inspired?
Only rule is you have to explain your reasoning.
First thought was Nathan Fyfe, but I'll think on it.