Top 10 - Jack Dyer Medal 2011 | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Top 10 - Jack Dyer Medal 2011

Smoking Aces

Smoking Aces

GOAT Week!
Sep 21, 2007
22,693
23,160
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/the-battle-to-be-best-man/story-e6frf9jf-1226126875658

The Herald Sun have gone through each club and picked their respective top 3 in the B&F and also the winner.

So maybe its a good time to see who we think our top 10 in the B&F will be.

1. Cotchin
2. Deledio
3. Rance
4. Houli
5. Martin
6. Riewoldt
7. Nahas
8. Newman
9. Vickery
10. Grigg
 
I agree with the 10 but my order would be slghtly different
1. Cotchin
2. Deledio
3. Martin
4. Houli
5. Nahas
6. Rance
7. Riewoldt
8. Newman
9. Grigg
10. Vickery

The most improved player will be a close call. Rance , Vickery and Nahas all have claims . Best first year player could well be Batchelor with Conca a close 2nd.
 
1-Mcguane
2-Miller
3-Jackson
4-Edwards
5-Graham
6-Tuck
7-White
8-Morton
9-Post
10-Hislop
 
CptJonno2Madcow2005 said:
1-Mcguane
2-Miller
3-Jackson
4-Edwards
5-Graham
6-Tuck
7-White
8-Morton
9-Post
10-Hislop
Click to expand...

:hihi hoping GWS takes McGuane and his value is upped by his B&F?
 
1. Chimp
2. Lids
3. Rance
4. Houli
5. Bull
6. Nahas
7. Jack
8. Newman
9. Vickery
10. Grigg/Foley
 
1. Cotchin
2. Deledio
3. Houli
4. Rance
5. Martin
6. Vickery
7. Nahas
8. Newman
9. Riewoldt
10. Grigg
 
No idea about the top ten but i'll have a stab at the top 5

1) Lid's
2)Cotchin
3)Rance
4)Houli
5)Nahas
 
martyshire said:
Can someone remind me what the voting format is. This makes a big difference. Is it 5-4-3-2-1 each game from 4 different voters?
Click to expand...

The five members of the match committee cast votes for each player.  They can each give anything from zero to five votes per player, so the mazimum a player can get in a game is 25 votes. Five votes are awarded for an outstanding performance down to zero for a poor one.

Edit-  I haven't seen enough games to form much of an opinion about the results this year but I reckon, due to the voting system, that Sir Rancealot and Lids will go very close.  Our back men saw a lot of the ball this season.
 
rosy23 said:
The five members of the match committee cast votes for each player. They can each give anything from zero to five votes per player, so the mazimum a player can get in a game is 25 votes. Five votes are awarded for an outstanding performance down to zero for a poor one.

Edit- I haven't seen enough games to form much of an opinion about the results this year but I reckon, due to the voting system, that Sir Rancealot and Lids will go very close. Our back men saw a lot of the ball this season.
Click to expand...

Thanks Rosy!

In that case I'm going with:
1. Cotchin
2. Rance
3. Deledio
4. Vickery
5. Martin
6. Foley
7. Houli
8. Nahas
9. Riewoldt
10. Newman
 
Top 10 (if not the order) does seem fairly clear cut this year.
1) Cotchin
2) Deledio
3) Martin
4) Jack
5) Newman
6) Houli
7) Vickery
8) Rance
9) Nahas
10) Grigg

Only others I can think of who've played enough to potentially be in are Foley, King, Edwards and Jackson with only the first two showing any kind of form.
 
1 Cotchin
2 Deledio
3 Rance
4 Martin
5 Houli
6 Riewoldt
7 Foley
8 Grigg
9 Nahas
10 Newman
 
Based on our voting system

1.RANCE :eek:
2. Cotchin
3 Deledio
4 Martin
5 Houli
6 Newman
7 Nahas
8 Grigg
9 Riewoldt
10 King
 
1. Cotchin
2. Deledio
3. Martin
4. Houli
5. Rance
6. Foley
7. Nahas
8. Riewoldt
9. Newman
10. Vickery
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
< FORUM FOOTY ANYONE ?? | Compo picks >
Official PRE merch now on Redbubble!
Top Bottom