September '19 Ruckmen

[eZyT]

I posted this because I think its a very tricky question.

assume 1. we are playing finals, 2. all ruckman are fit and in form at VFL or AFL

Im going to vote Nank and Noah,

very difficult, but I like Balta's flexibility plugging a hole down back.

if we can get 100 votes, we have a fail proof answer.

 

[TigerMasochist]

Where's my cheese sanga n can I have a toasty please?

 

[Tigerfan]

I posted this because I think its a very tricky question.

assume 1. we are playing finals, 2. all ruckman are fit and in form at VFL or AFL

Im going to vote Nank and Noah,

very difficult, but I like Balta's flexibility plugging a hole down back.

if we can get 100 votes, we have a fail proof answer.

It’s a great question.
Best poll ever!

 

[TigerForce]

Nank & Cholly.

 

[MB78]

Nank and Mabs for me.

It’s a good problem to have both Mabs and Noah in competition for that spot as they will need to stay in form or they will be in the VFL.

 

[spook]

It's definitely Nank and Noah or Chol. I have Chol in front as a forward presence who can relieve Nank. Noah has the edge as a follower.

Soldo has done exactly what we needed him to but he and Nank should never play in the same side. He's back-up number 1. For what we paid he's outstanding value.

 

[The_Celebrant]

It's definitely Nank and Noah or Chol. I have Chol in front as a forward presence who can relieve Nank. Noah has the edge as a follower.

I think Noah is being groomed in the magoos as a back-up key defender.

With Rance gone, if Astbury goes down we are really light on – at this stage, Garth is Astbury Lite at best, especially if he had to take the oppo's best forward.

If he's needed again this year, Noah could man the likes of Jack Darling in a final, not let him off the chain, and sprint forward at times to make Darling accountable.

Noah needs a season or two for his footy smarts to catch up with his body. Then he might be the best player in the comp, a cross between Koutafides and Pharlap.

 

[spook]

I think Noah is being groomed in the magoos as a back-up key defender.

With Rance gone, if Astbury goes down we are really light on – at this stage, Garth is Astbury Lite at best, especially if he had to take the oppo's best forward.

If he's needed again this year, Noah could man the likes of Jack Darling in a final, not let him off the chain, and sprint forward at times to make Darling accountable.

Noah needs a season or two for his footy smarts to catch up with his body. Then he might be the best player in the comp, a cross between Koutafides and Pharlap.

100%

 

[123cups]

Nankervis + Caddy.

 

[eZyT]

Jeez big Ivan made this a whole lot tougher today.

He was pretty colossal. He got effective taps, he planted in front of Dixon, he took marks, and goal

having said all that, I think someone else said it well.

He's a back up 1st ruck, rather than a 2nd Ruck to Nank.

on that basis, I go with Nank and Mabior against the Pies

 

[eddazol]

Rucked well