Here is what I saw after reviewing the game twice and once on radio......
Hartigan - tried hard but was well beaten
Rating 3
Hall - great mark under real pressure and did some good things all night. Kept his opposite number VERY quiet
Rating 7
Gaspar - not much game time and did little
Rating 0
Roach - not much game time did some nice things when on
Rating 1
A Kellaway - Solid game with a few mistakes
Rating 6
W Campbell - Top game and major inspiration in the first quarter, continued all night - one of the best
Rating 8
Chaffey - Started well on the wing but casued a gola turnover when in defence curbing the major opposition goalkicker
Rating 6
Tivendale - Outstanding first half, faded and flashed in and out after that
Rating 8.5
Rodan - Better to forget and please take 2-3 weeks to get your confidence up at coburg
Rating 0
Krakouer - Did nice things but not at his best. expected him to burn in front of goals
Rating 6
Marsh - Very slow and unable to match it with Spider
Rating 2
Ottens - Best game I have seen him play this year, but still not at best
Rating 7
Fiora - did a real job running off Smith and negated his play. Whoever came up with this well done, lets leave him forward for the rest of the season
Rating 8
*smile* - Needs more game time but was a handy target - needs to be a goalkicker if he is to play as a major forward
Rating 4
Fletcher - Some time on field but did not have impact
Rating 0
Hyde - Best game for the Tigers - hopefully now he can get more game time after this effort
Rating 8.5
Johnson - Consistently good for the duration of the game, probably best throughout and did not fade in and out.
Rating 8.5
Hilton - Bagged by many here and is obviously not fit yet but did add significant spark to what has been a very dull forward line. Kicked three and helped get at least two others. Faded out in late 3rd Q
Rating 7.5
Brown - excellent first Q, thereafter was off the boil especially after half time and overshadowed by Crawford. Probably his worst game for the Tigers so far - but dont read it was bad - just his others have been so much better
Rating 6
Fleming - This guy is an average player who just gives his all. gets bagged a lot but I wish we had 22 who had his heart and go. Skills are below average and neeeds to work hard on negating his opposite player. Did really go for it when trying to put us in front, check out how he accelerated from his hawk opponent
Rating 5.5
Newman - Came out and playe very well despite copping what I thought to be a reportable Charge from 21 VDB of the Hawks. Watch the replay - very clear he went for the player.
Rating 7.5
Weller - Another bagged on this site but really stood up to be counted. His opposite number was well held and when moved to CHF in the last quarter was one of our best. Delivered the ball ok and marked well.
Rating 7
Hartigan - tried hard but was well beaten
Rating 3
Hall - great mark under real pressure and did some good things all night. Kept his opposite number VERY quiet
Rating 7
Gaspar - not much game time and did little
Rating 0
Roach - not much game time did some nice things when on
Rating 1
A Kellaway - Solid game with a few mistakes
Rating 6
W Campbell - Top game and major inspiration in the first quarter, continued all night - one of the best
Rating 8
Chaffey - Started well on the wing but casued a gola turnover when in defence curbing the major opposition goalkicker
Rating 6
Tivendale - Outstanding first half, faded and flashed in and out after that
Rating 8.5
Rodan - Better to forget and please take 2-3 weeks to get your confidence up at coburg
Rating 0
Krakouer - Did nice things but not at his best. expected him to burn in front of goals
Rating 6
Marsh - Very slow and unable to match it with Spider
Rating 2
Ottens - Best game I have seen him play this year, but still not at best
Rating 7
Fiora - did a real job running off Smith and negated his play. Whoever came up with this well done, lets leave him forward for the rest of the season
Rating 8
*smile* - Needs more game time but was a handy target - needs to be a goalkicker if he is to play as a major forward
Rating 4
Fletcher - Some time on field but did not have impact
Rating 0
Hyde - Best game for the Tigers - hopefully now he can get more game time after this effort
Rating 8.5
Johnson - Consistently good for the duration of the game, probably best throughout and did not fade in and out.
Rating 8.5
Hilton - Bagged by many here and is obviously not fit yet but did add significant spark to what has been a very dull forward line. Kicked three and helped get at least two others. Faded out in late 3rd Q
Rating 7.5
Brown - excellent first Q, thereafter was off the boil especially after half time and overshadowed by Crawford. Probably his worst game for the Tigers so far - but dont read it was bad - just his others have been so much better
Rating 6
Fleming - This guy is an average player who just gives his all. gets bagged a lot but I wish we had 22 who had his heart and go. Skills are below average and neeeds to work hard on negating his opposite player. Did really go for it when trying to put us in front, check out how he accelerated from his hawk opponent
Rating 5.5
Newman - Came out and playe very well despite copping what I thought to be a reportable Charge from 21 VDB of the Hawks. Watch the replay - very clear he went for the player.
Rating 7.5
Weller - Another bagged on this site but really stood up to be counted. His opposite number was well held and when moved to CHF in the last quarter was one of our best. Delivered the ball ok and marked well.
Rating 7
