Penalty shoot out

[TigerMad]

Would love the AFL to introduce this when the scores are tied.
Probably 5 players from each team would kick from in front of goal, about 30 to forty metres out.

Question is, which 5 Richmond players (in order) would you choose to take the kick? Do we have 5?

 

[davidrodan]

Lids, Tuck, Newman, Chimpa, maybe Rance after this week or Martin

 

[Go The Tiges!]

Deledio
Vickery
Rance
Newman
Martin

Really struggled coming up with 5

 

[hopper]

Jackson
Edwards
McGuane
Graham
Hislop

..... hey, we're tanking aren't we?! I'm not letting another McMahon incident prevent our re-build!

 

[Phar Ace]

Jackson
Edwards
McGuane
Graham
Hislop

..... hey, we're tanking aren't we?! I'm not letting another McMahon incident prevent our re-build!

;D

But you would have to do it from 50m wouldn't you? I'd especially like it from that distance to contrast from all this short kick to possession style footy we are getting overdosed on!

Newman
Deledio
Tuck
Nason
Collins

 

[TigerMad]

So ignoring Hopper.....of the players nominated so far....

The only current forward trusted enough would be recent ex defender Rance (3 goals in 2010, all last game)
and resting ruckman Vickery (one goal in 2010)?

Mmmmm on second thoughts lets keep the system the way it is .........

 

[taztiger4]

Jackson
Edwards
McGuane
Graham
Hislop

..... hey, we're tanking aren't we?! I'm not letting another McMahon incident prevent our re-build!

add Hislop & cousins !

 

[mexican_radio]

I thought the title of this topic was an idea to replace next weekends game against Geelong.

 

[ZeroGame]

Deledio
Newman
Tuck
Vickery
Martin

 

[Baloo]

Deledio
Newman
Jackson
Martin
Tuck

 

[LeeToRainesToRoach]

Deledio
Morton
Tuck
Cousins
McMahon


Career goalkicking accuracy, with number of scoring kicks:

100% Astbury    3
86% Vickery    7
80% Collins  10
68% Thomson  25
67% Rance      6
67% Hislop    18
65% Morton  144
63% Cotchin  19
63% Graham    8
62% Cousins  340
62% Tuck      87
61% Deledio  147
61% Simmonds 217
60% Nason      5
60% Connors  10
59% Foley    37
58% White    36
58% Riewoldt 116
57% Edwards  51
57% McMahon  81
53% Nahas    47
52% Tambling 114
46% Jackson  41
46% Polo      24
46% Moore    24
45% Newman    44
45% Polak    56
43% King      21
40% Martin    5
40% Taylor    5
33% McGuane    6
33% Post      9
  0% Roberts   2
  0% Farmer    1

 

[rowdydave]

mmm..a tie!

If only we could get that close.




Rowdydave.

 

[geoffryprettyboy]

Give all 5 to Vickery.